The same amount of energy consumption can produce two different Scope 2 results – and both may be correct. It depends on whether emissions are calculated using the location-based or market-based method. We explain the differences between these approaches, the role of Guarantees of Origin, supplier data and residual mix, and how NEOGAGE Carbon Footprint helps structure Scope 2 calculations.
The same electricity bill. The same energy consumption in MWh. Two different Scope 2 emissions results.
And both may be correct.
This is because, under the GHG Protocol, emissions associated with purchased energy can be calculated using two different approaches: the location-based method and the market-based method.
The first reflects the emissions intensity of the energy system in the geographical area where electricity is consumed.
The second takes into account information about the energy an organisation purchases and the qualifying contractual instruments that can be associated with that consumption.
The difference is not merely methodological.
It can significantly affect the reported Scope 2 result, the assessment of renewable electricity procurement and year-on-year emissions comparisons.
A correct Scope 2 calculation should therefore answer not only:
“How much energy did we consume?”
but also:
“Which accounting method are we using, and which data can we reliably apply?”
What is Scope 2?
Scope 2 covers indirect greenhouse gas emissions associated with the generation of purchased or acquired energy consumed by an organisation.
It primarily includes:
- electricity,
- heating,
- steam,
- cooling.
These emissions do not occur directly in facilities owned or controlled by the reporting organisation, which is why they are not classified as Scope 1.
However, they arise as a consequence of the energy purchased and consumed by the organisation.
A manufacturing company that does not operate its own power plant but purchases electricity from the grid is a simple example.
The emissions associated with generating that electricity are accounted for under Scope 2.
At first glance, the calculation appears straightforward:
energy consumption × relevant emission factor = Scope 2 emissions
The key question, however, is:
Which emission factor should be used?
The answer depends, among other factors, on whether the calculation follows the location-based or market-based method.
What is the location-based method?
The location-based method reflects emissions based on the characteristics of the energy system in the geographical area where energy is consumed.
The calculation primarily relies on average grid emission factors applicable to a specific geographical area or electricity system.
In simplified form:
energy consumption × grid emission factor = location-based Scope 2 emissions
This method therefore answers the question:
“What is the average emissions intensity of the electricity system in the location where we operate?”
If a company operates facilities in several countries, it should not automatically apply the same emission factor to every location.
National electricity systems can be based on very different energy sources.
One country may rely heavily on fossil fuels, while another may have a significant share of nuclear power, hydropower or renewable energy.
Geography is therefore fundamental to location-based Scope 2 accounting.
What is the market-based method?
The market-based method looks at Scope 2 from a different perspective.
It does not focus solely on the average characteristics of the electricity grid.
Instead, it takes into account information about the energy an organisation has purchased and qualifying contractual instruments associated with that consumption.
These may include:
- supplier-specific emissions data,
- specific electricity products,
- Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs),
- Guarantees of Origin or other energy attribute certificates,
- appropriate residual mix values where qualifying contractual information is unavailable.
However, this does not mean that every electricity contract marketed as “green energy” can automatically be used in a market-based calculation.
The GHG Protocol defines quality criteria that contractual instruments and related data should meet when used for market-based Scope 2 accounting.
Before applying a particular document or emission factor, an organisation therefore needs to verify not only its name, but also what it actually represents.
Location-based vs market-based – key differences
The location-based method primarily reflects the characteristics of the electricity system in the place where energy is consumed.
The market-based method reflects an organisation’s energy purchasing choices, provided that those choices can be supported by appropriate data and qualifying contractual instruments.
In simplified terms:
LOCATION-BASED
- Reference point: location of energy consumption,
- Data: average grid emission factors,
- Key question: what is the emissions intensity of the electricity system in this location?
MARKET-BASED
- Reference point: energy procurement,
- Data: qualifying contractual instruments, supplier data and relevant emission factors,
- Key question: which energy attributes can be reliably assigned to the purchased electricity?
The two methods can therefore produce different results.
This does not automatically mean that one result is correct and the other is wrong.
They represent two different perspectives on purchased energy emissions.
When should both Scope 2 results be reported?
The GHG Protocol Scope 2 Guidance establishes the concept of dual reporting.
For organisations operating in markets where product- or supplier-specific data and qualifying contractual instruments are available, Scope 2 emissions are reported using both:
- the location-based method,
- the market-based method.
This means that an organisation may report two Scope 2 results for the same reporting period.
However, these results should not be combined or presented without clearly identifying the method used.
The report should make it clear which result represents the location-based calculation and which represents the market-based calculation.
This approach improves transparency and helps distinguish the influence of the local electricity system from the effects of an organisation’s energy procurement decisions.
Guarantees of Origin, PPAs and supplier data – what really matters?
One common oversimplification is:
“We have Guarantees of Origin, so our Scope 2 emissions are zero.”
That conclusion goes too far.
Guarantees of Origin may be an important part of a market-based calculation, but an organisation needs to verify whether the instrument meets the relevant requirements and can be correctly matched to the reported electricity consumption.
The same principle applies to Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs).
Signing a PPA does not remove the need to verify:
- what exactly the agreement covers,
- which energy attributes are transferred,
- which reporting period it applies to,
- which location or market it covers,
- whether the same attributes have already been assigned to another consumer.
Supplier-specific emission factors should be treated with the same level of care.
The data need to be reliable, appropriate for the reporting period and compatible with the methodology being applied.
What is residual mix?
Residual mix represents the remaining electricity mix after specific energy attributes have already been allocated to consumers through recognised contractual instruments.
It is particularly relevant to the market-based method.
If renewable energy attributes have already been assigned to customers holding the relevant certificates or contractual instruments, those same attributes should not be assigned again to consumers who do not hold them.
Otherwise, the same environmental attributes could effectively be counted twice.
In certain situations where an organisation does not have qualifying contractual information, the residual mix may therefore become the appropriate reference point for market-based reporting.
This is one reason why market-based accounting should not simply be equated with using a “supplier emission factor”.
The method requires an assessment of the hierarchy and quality of the available data.
Does renewable electricity mean zero Scope 2 emissions?
This should never be assumed automatically.
The statement:
“100% renewable electricity”
is not, by itself, sufficient to determine a Scope 2 result.
An organisation should verify:
- how the electricity was purchased,
- which documents confirm its energy attributes,
- whether the instruments can be used under the market-based method,
- which period and electricity volume they cover,
- which emission factor should be applied.
At the same time, the location-based result may remain significantly higher because this method continues to reflect the average emissions intensity of the electricity grid in the relevant location.
An organisation may therefore simultaneously report:
a higher location-based Scope 2 result
and
a lower market-based Scope 2 result.
This is not necessarily a contradiction.
It is a consequence of applying two different accounting methods.
What data are required to calculate Scope 2?
Reliable energy consumption data are the starting point.
Depending on the organisation, these data may come from:
- electricity and energy bills,
- utility meters,
- sub-meters,
- energy management systems,
- individual site records,
- electricity and heat suppliers.
Additional information is required to select the correct method and emission factor, including:
- location of energy consumption,
- consumption period,
- energy supplier,
- type of energy,
- emission factor used,
- source of the emission factor,
- information on the energy mix,
- relevant contractual documentation,
- Guarantees of Origin or other instruments where applicable.
For organisations operating across multiple legal entities and locations, consistent data collection rules become particularly important.
How to calculate Scope 2 step by step
Step 1. Collect energy consumption data
Determine the actual consumption of electricity, heating, steam or cooling for all locations included within the organisational reporting boundary.
Step 2. Assign the data to the correct reporting period
Energy consumption and emission factors should correspond to the appropriate reporting period.
A current emission factor should not automatically be applied to historical consumption data.
Step 3. Identify the location of consumption
This is essential for the location-based method.
Facilities operating in different countries may require different grid emission factors.
Step 4. Verify available contractual information
Determine whether the organisation has access to:
- supplier-specific data,
- Guarantees of Origin,
- PPAs,
- other instruments relating to the attributes of purchased electricity.
Do not assume that every document automatically meets the requirements of the market-based method.
Step 5. Select the appropriate emission factors
For the location-based method, the calculation will primarily use appropriate grid-average emission factors.
For the market-based method, the relevant data hierarchy should be applied based on available and qualifying contractual information.
Step 6. Calculate the emissions
The basic formula remains the same:
energy consumption × relevant emission factor = Scope 2 emissions
What changes is the type of emission factor used.
Step 7. Document the methodology and data sources
Record:
- consumption,
- source of consumption data,
- emission factor,
- source of the factor,
- database version or year,
- calculation method,
- documentation relating to contractual instruments.
This makes it possible to reproduce and verify the calculation later.
The most common Scope 2 calculation errors
Error 1. Reporting only one result without checking whether dual reporting applies
Where an organisation operates in a market subject to dual reporting requirements, presenting only one Scope 2 result may not provide the full information required under the GHG Protocol Scope 2 Guidance.
Error 2. Treating location-based and market-based as two names for the same calculation
They are two different accounting approaches.
The key difference lies in the information used to determine the emissions associated with purchased energy.
Error 3. Assuming that a “green tariff” automatically means zero emissions
A marketing label is not sufficient.
The underlying data and instruments supporting the energy attributes must be verified.
Error 4. Using the same emission factor for every location
This can be particularly problematic for organisations operating across several countries.
Error 5. Ignoring the reporting year
Electricity mixes and emission factors change over time.
Using a factor from the wrong year can distort both the result and trend analysis.
Error 6. Mixing results from the two methods
An organisation should not select the lowest values from the two approaches and combine them into one result.
Each method should be calculated and reported according to its own rules.
Error 7. Failing to maintain adequate documentation
If, a year later, nobody knows where an emission factor came from or which Guarantee of Origin was assigned to a specific volume of electricity, reproducing the calculation may become extremely difficult.
What is changing in the GHG Protocol Scope 2 framework?
The GHG Protocol is currently working on an update to its Scope 2 Guidance.
Public consultations on proposed methodological changes took place in 2025–2026.
The discussions have included areas such as:
- the accuracy of data used in location-based accounting,
- requirements for market-based data,
- temporal matching between electricity generation and consumption,
- deliverability of electricity to a particular market,
- treatment and reporting of market-based instruments.
At the time of publication of this article, the update process is still ongoing.
Current Scope 2 calculations should therefore continue to follow the applicable GHG Protocol Scope 2 Guidance, while organisations with long-term reporting processes should monitor further developments.
This is particularly relevant for companies with long-term electricity procurement contracts or Scope 2 reduction strategies based on specific market instruments.
How NEOGAGE Carbon Footprint supports Scope 2 calculations
For a single location, collecting energy consumption data may appear relatively straightforward.
The challenge increases with the number of:
- companies and legal entities,
- facilities,
- suppliers,
- meters,
- reporting periods,
- data sources,
- emission factors.
NEOGAGE Carbon Footprint helps organisations manage the data required for Scope 1, Scope 2 and Scope 3 calculations within one structured environment.
In the context of Scope 2, the system supports, among other functions:
- defining organisational structures, locations and branches,
- recording Scope 2 emissions,
- adding energy mixes for electricity suppliers,
- using available emission factor databases,
- defining custom emission factors,
- setting default emission factors,
- automatically selecting emission factors according to the emission date,
- generating reports containing information about the emission factors used,
- analysing trends and comparing results across reporting periods.
In NEOGAGE Carbon Footprint 2.8.0, the available resources were also expanded to include new emission factor databases for electricity and heat suppliers in Poland for 2025.
However, the system does not replace methodological judgement.
The user remains responsible for determining which data and instruments are appropriate for the selected accounting method and whether they meet the relevant requirements.
The role of NEOGAGE is to structure the process, data and calculation history so that results can also be analysed and reproduced in future reporting periods.
Checklist before finalising your Scope 2 calculation
Before approving the final result, verify:
- Have energy consumption data been collected for all locations included in the reporting boundary?
- Have the data been assigned to the correct reporting period?
- Have appropriate emission factors been applied to each location?
- Have location-based and market-based methods been clearly distinguished?
- Has the requirement for dual reporting been assessed?
- Have contractual instruments been checked against the relevant criteria?
- Has double claiming of energy attributes been avoided?
- Have the appropriate supplier data or residual mix values been used where required?
- Have the year, source and unit of each emission factor been recorded?
- Can the calculation be reproduced in the next reporting period?
If the answer to any of these questions is “I don’t know”, that element should be reviewed before the final result is published.
Conclusion
Scope 2 is much more than multiplying the number of MWh consumed by a single emission factor.
The location-based method reflects the emissions intensity of the electricity system in the place where energy is consumed.
The market-based method, on the other hand, takes into account appropriately documented information relating to energy procurement and energy attributes.
The same organisation may therefore obtain two different Scope 2 results.
The objective is not to choose whichever result looks more favourable.
The objective is to apply each method correctly, use appropriate data and retain complete information about the sources, emission factors and assumptions used.
NEOGAGE Carbon Footprint helps structure this process – from energy consumption data and organisational structures to emission factors, analysis and reporting.
FAQ – Scope 2, location-based and market-based
What does Scope 2 include?
Scope 2 covers indirect greenhouse gas emissions associated with the generation of purchased or acquired energy, primarily electricity, heating, steam and cooling consumed by an organisation.
What is the difference between location-based and market-based Scope 2?
The location-based method primarily uses the average emissions intensity of the electricity system in the location where energy is consumed. The market-based method uses qualifying data and contractual instruments associated with the way electricity is purchased.
Can a company report two different Scope 2 results?
Yes. Under dual reporting, location-based and market-based results may differ because the two methods use different approaches to determine emissions from purchased energy.
Do Guarantees of Origin automatically mean zero Scope 2 emissions?
No. Organisations need to verify whether the relevant instruments meet the applicable market-based criteria and can be correctly matched to the reported electricity consumption.
Does renewable electricity always mean zero emissions?
No. The result depends on the accounting method, applicable emission factor and the available qualifying data. The location-based result may remain above zero even where an organisation holds instruments relating to renewable electricity.
What is residual mix?
Residual mix represents the remaining electricity mix after specific energy attributes have already been allocated to consumers. It may be relevant to market-based calculations where qualifying contractual information is unavailable.
Does Scope 2 only cover electricity?
No. Scope 2 also includes purchased heating, steam and cooling where that energy is generated outside the organisation’s reporting boundary and subsequently consumed by the organisation.
Do location-based and market-based results need to be reported together?
Under certain conditions, the GHG Protocol Scope 2 Guidance requires dual reporting, meaning that results are disclosed using both methods. This applies where the relevant market offers appropriate product- or supplier-specific data and contractual instruments.
Are the Scope 2 rules changing in 2026?
The GHG Protocol is working on an update to the Scope 2 Guidance. Public consultations were conducted during 2025–2026, but at the time of publication the revised framework has not yet replaced the existing guidance.
How does NEOGAGE Carbon Footprint support Scope 2 calculations?
NEOGAGE Carbon Footprint supports Scope 1, Scope 2 and Scope 3 calculations, organisational and location structures, emission factor databases and custom factors, supplier energy mixes, date-based emission factor selection, and reporting that records the factors used in the calculation.